News posted by

UMCSC grieves after retired pastor found dead

By Jessica Brodie

SALUDA—United Methodists across South Carolina are mourning this month after an ailing retired pastor reportedly died from neglect and abuse at the hands of his son and daughter-in-law.

The Rev. James Boyd Chewning, 79, died Nov. 2. His son and daughter-in-law, Donald Ralph Chewning and Kathy Laine Chewning, have been arrested and charged with felony abuse or neglect of a vulnerable adult resulting in death.

According to the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division, the case was investigated by SLED at the request of the Saluda Police Department. If convicted, the Chewnings face up to 30 years in prison. The warrant affidavit said the late pastor was “battered, restrained to a bed using zip ties, and rags and duct tape were used to cover the victim’s mouth and eyes.”

South Carolina Resident Bishop Jonathan Holston called for prayer and an increased awareness of those vulnerable to neglect and abuse.

“The passing of the Rev. Boyd Chewning weighs heavily upon my heart and the hearts of all of those who were touched by his ministry, which stretched over more than 40 years at United Methodist churches across South Carolina,” Holston said. “We are in prayer for those who loved Rev. Chewning, and we grieve his loss throughout the Methodist connection. The allegations of neglect and abuse serve as a reminder of our obligation as Christians to look out for the defenseless among us. It also presents an opportunity to reaffirm our Safe Sanctuaries Policy, which represents ‘our total and unwavering commitment to the physical, emotional and spiritual safety of all … vulnerable adults.’”

Chewning was ordained as a full elder in the South Carolina Conference in 1965, two years after his first appointment t the Union Charge. He served churches in eight of the conference’s 12 districts. When he retired in 2004, he was pastor of Emory UMC, Saluda, and Nazareth UMC, near Batesburg-Leesville.

His memorial service was held Nov. 15 in the Nancy Freeman Stringer Chapel at The Oaks.

Regarding abuse, the UMC Social Principles state, “We recognize that family violence and abuse in all its forms—verbal, psychological, physical, sexual—is detrimental to the covenant of the human community. … Regardless of the cause or the abuse, both the victim and the abuser need the love of the Church. While we deplore the actions of the abuser, we affirm that person to be in need of God’s redeeming love.”


  • It awakens all of us to the fact that harm is continually inflected on the vornuable amog us. We pray that someway and somehow evil will disappear from the minds of people given the responsibility to care for the elderly and the very young.


  • Yes. We grieve with South Carolina Churches for those who like The Retired Methodist Minister mentioned who experienced this terrible ending to a life as The Lords Servant so unjustly and in such a cruel manner. The Lord sees all and no person or persons will go unpunished. He takes these crimes to His Heart of Love and Justice. God forgive them for they do not know what they do. Rest In Peace, dear Servant of The Lord, in His Presence, forever more. Amen. In Jesus Name.

  • Why wasn’t anyone aware of this? Didn’t he have any other family or past members of his church come to visit him? What a horrible end for this wonderful man.

  • Boyd and I were seminary classmates at Emory and this breaks my heart. What a terrible and painful way to spend one’s last days.
    Queon Smith

  • I grieve with South Carolina UM Churches, with the members of the Conference, with the Bishop, but at the same time, I try to understand why the Conferences of the UMC don’t have a program for visiting the Retired Pastors, to know how they live, and if they are facing neglect and abuse. Who can answer?

  • Rev. Chewing was always kind to me when I was a young pastor in the SC Conference, thus I am heartbroken and horrified by this news. As a law enforcement chaplain and the husband of a criminal prosecutor, I am furious and I want justice! Our Safe Sanctuaries policy dictates maximum protection for children and vulnerable adults in our midst. This should extend far beyond the walls of our churches and into the communities where we live and work. Any violation of that policy should be met with maximum resistance, no matter whom the offender might be.

  • Mr. Chewing was our minister at Bethlehem United Methodist Church in Hannah, SC in the 70’s. I was only a child, but I do remember him. I’m sorry to hear of his awful passing. May he rest in peace.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contact Us

Advocate, 4908 Colonial Drive, Columbia, SC 29203 | 803-786-9486 |

Social Media